Fictional example · Day 2 reconciliation

Stillwater Print Jury

Print category · Round 1 · One place on the next-review list

6 of 6 scores received · 2 of 2 entries complete

Tie review · Keep E12 and E17 together for the next review.

E12 · Tidal Lines

J1 4J2 5J3 5

3 of 3 · Tie review

14 ÷ 3 ≈ 4.67 · Complete mean

E17 · Salt Window

J1 5J2 4J3 5

3 of 3 · Tie review

14 ÷ 3 ≈ 4.67 · Complete mean

Scoring and handoff

Each slot supplies one whole-number score from 1 to 5 for how the composition guides the eye. Use 1 if the intended focal point is hard to locate, 3 if it is clear but competing marks pull attention, and 5 if the marks consistently guide attention. Use 2 and 4 between those descriptions.

J1, J2 and J3 carry equal weight. Count only scores received. Round to two decimals for display and compare the exact totals after all three scores arrive for both entries.

Day 2: J3 supplied 5 for E12. Both entries total 14, so the coordinator records both IDs for the next review under the event’s procedure.