Fictional example

Research poster review: courtyard shade study

This invented practice record keeps poster evidence, readability, a two-minute explanation, and question response in separate observable criteria.

Review copy C24 of 24 points2 earlier revisions completed

Do shade panels change surface temperature?

Fictional environmental science poster

Claim: In this invented comparison, the shaded courtyard surface was cooler at the recorded midday check.
41°COpen paving
31°CShade panel

Fictional surface temperature (°C) at one midday observation

Method: One invented reading was recorded at each marked location with the same fictional instrument.

Result and conclusion: The invented shaded reading was 10°C lower. This supports only the narrow comparison shown; it does not establish a general cooling effect.

Source: fictional observation record C-14 · recorded May 12, 2026 · teaching example only

Viewing-distance check: category labels, values, unit, source line, and limit were read from the intended standing position in this fictional review.

Two-minute explanation cue

Opening: “This fictional poster asks whether the marked shade panel and open paving differed at one midday check.”

Method: Point to both locations and the same-instrument condition.

Result: Point to 41°C and 31°C, name the 10°C difference, and identify the °C unit.

Conclusion and limit: Say that the invented reading supports this comparison only, not a general cooling claim.

Question: “Does this prove shade panels always cool paving?”

Response: “No. This example contains one invented observation at two marked locations. Repeated observations and an approved study design would be needed for a broader conclusion.”

Reviewer record

Observed first
Category labels were too small and the source line was missing.
Scores affected
Figure evidence 1/3; labels and source trail 1/3.
Actions
Enlarge both category labels. Add a dated fictional source record line.
Recheck
Read the labels at the planned distance and trace the figure to the source line.
Completed
Both actions visible in Review copy C.
Course fields
Replace audience, discipline conventions, required sections, scale, weights, accessibility needs, and grading policy before use.