Digitization scan quality control log

Find a clipped edge or a tilted scan, then record what you see when you open the replacement under the same sample ID.

In the fictional Field Cards batch, a pair of red boxes near the right edge of page P06 disappeared in the scan. The rules across the page still looked straight. We recorded the clipped edge and left the replacement fields empty until we could open P06-v2 and check the same landmarks.

Download the blank scan sample log to start your own check. The completed CSV keeps the first pass and recheck side by side. Use the complete HTML exercise to inspect the fictional scans offline.

Where do you look for clipped edges and tilt?

Open the delivered scan beside the reference for the same page. Zoom out far enough to see all four edges, then zoom in at any edge that looks tight. Look for a border, a mark, or a line that ends differently between the two files. On P06-v1, the ruled lines stop at the crop and the right border and red boxes are missing.

Use a straight feature that appears in both images for the tilt check. The horizontal rules in P06-draft slope down toward the right. Those same rules run level in the reference and in P06-v1. P06-draft is a practice file for the same page. The first-pass count uses P06-v1.

NOS View showing level rules in the reference, sloped rules in the practice file and clipping in P06-v1
Compare the rules first. Then look for the two red boxes near the right border of the reference.

If a page is irregular, compare features inside the image with the same features in the reference. Record “Unable to verify” when the reference or a usable landmark is missing. Leave a note about what the next reviewer needs to see.

What belongs in the sample row?

Enter the batch, total page count, selected page ID, reference and exact file version. Use separate fields for the edge and tilt observations. On P06, mark the edge “Clipped,” record “No visible difference” for tilt, and describe which marks disappeared. Write the next action on the same row. Keep the replacement filename and both recheck fields blank while the replacement is pending.

NOS Edit mode showing the P06 first-pass result and the pending replacement fields
The P06 entry still says recheck pending. A replacement filename alone would leave both visual observations open.

The two checks in this exercise come from visual inspection practice. The National Library of the Netherlands case study describes looking for cropping and straightness. An Indiana University case study describes inspecting a sample alongside automated file checks.

How do you close the recheck?

Open P06-v2 beside the same P06 reference. Look for the full right border and both red boxes, then check that the ruled lines still align with the reference. Enter the replacement and its observations under P06. Preserve the original file version and the note about the cut-off marks. With both checks recorded, mark the row “Rechecked.”

NOS Code mode showing the Field Cards log source alongside its first-pass preview
The sample log is an HTML page. Its first-pass preview shows two pages meeting both checks and the open P06 recheck.
NOS Share panel showing the viewer link for the Field Cards exercise
Share shows the viewer address for the log. A colleague can use it to read the next update.
Signed-out NOS reader showing P06-v1 and its pending recheck
The reader address initially showed P06-v1 with a clipped right edge and a pending recheck.
Same NOS reader page showing the restored border and red boxes in P06-v2
At the same reader address, P06-v2 shows the full border and both boxes. The original finding is still visible under P06.

How do you report the result without overstating coverage?

Divide the inspected pages by the number listed in the batch. Here, 3 ÷ 12 = 25%. Of those three pages, two met both checks on the first pass, so 2 ÷ 3 is about 66.7%. After reopening P06-v2, 3 ÷ 3 = 100% of the sample met both checks. The same 3 of 12 pages were inspected. The other 9 of 12 pages (75%) remain unchecked.

Count each sampled page once when you summarize the latest results. Keep the first pass and any replacements as observations on that page’s row.

When not to do this

Follow the sampling and acceptance requirements for your project when you need batch sign-off, a formal deposit or a technical image assessment. This exercise records two visual observations on designated pages. For a different handoff, use a building photo log to recover a camera position, or a content inventory to reconcile supplied lists.

How can you send the checked example?

We kept the fictional scan comparisons and the recheck row on one NOS Workspace page. After updating the log, we reopened the same read-only Field Cards example signed out and saw P06-v2. Keep your own reference files and working log in the location your project uses.

Questions people ask

Do I need a fresh sample ID when a replacement arrives?

Keep the page’s ID. Record the replacement version and its observations in the recheck fields on the original row.

What if I can see the edges but cannot judge tilt?

Record the edge observation separately and mark tilt Unable to verify. Add the missing reference or landmark to your follow-up note.

What should a blank recheck field mean?

It means there is no observation in that field. Use the status to show whether a replacement is pending or the first file already met both checks.

Does a clean sample tell me that the whole batch passes?

The sample result describes only the pages you opened and the checks you made. Record the batch count and the unchecked pages beside it.

Keep reading